Decrease in bankruptcies corresponds with filing fee increase
In The Australian Financial Review on 8 October 2010 (Priest, “Bankruptcies hit three-year low”, page 3) a decline in the number of bankruptcies was attributed to recent amendments to the Bankruptcy Act which had the effect of increasing the minimum debt amount to commence bankruptcy proceedings to $5,000 (up from $2,000). The article claimed that during the September 2010 quarter the rate of bankruptcies fell by 9% - the largest decrease for three years.
There can be little doubt that the increase in the minimum threshold debt amount has contributed to the recent decline in the number of bankruptcies (the article mentions that in 2008-09, 9% of all bankruptcies related to debts between $2,000 and $5,000). However, another contributing factor which may have been overlooked (given that the recent amendments to the minimum debt amount did not commence until 11 August 2010) is that on 1 July 2010 amendments to the Federal Court of Australia Regulations 2004 (Cth) took effect. Those amendments substantially increased the court fees that are payable when a creditor’s petition is filed. The table below demonstrates the size of the increase:
|
Applicant |
Old Fee |
Current Fee |
% increase |
|
Corporation |
$745.00 |
$1,983.00 |
166% |
|
Individual |
$374.00 |
$828.00 |
121% |
While the bankruptcy process does not exist to assist creditors with the collection of debts, in practice it is often used exactly for that purpose, especially when a debtor has a genuine inability to pay all of his or her debts. In that context, the cost of bankruptcy proceedings is usually a factor considered by most creditors when deciding whether to use bankruptcy as an enforcement remedy. While filing fees are usually recoverable by the petitioning creditor from the bankrupt estate (provided that the estate has sufficient funds), the recent fees hike means that a creditor now needs to be even more careful when considering whether it is commercial to bankrupt a debtor over a relatively small debt.
The cost of access to the courts should not be overlooked when analysing trends in bankruptcy. Attributing the recent decline in bankruptcy numbers to an increase in the minimum debt threshold may be too simplistic, given the careful commercial considerations made by creditors when deciding to use bankruptcy as an enforcement option.
To discuss further, please contact:
Scott Guthrie| Partner
T +61 7 3100 5019
Andrew Vella| Associate
T +61 7 3100 5134
More contacts:
Wendy Jacobs| Partner
T +61 2 8233 9537
John Hill | Partner
T +61 2 6201 7200